Regional assessment of status and trends in metal concentrations in biota

Overview

The following sections:

  • summarise the individual time series results
  • describe the methods used to combine the individual time series results to estimate regional trends and status
  • present the estimates of regional trends
  • present the estimates of regional status


Summary of individual time series results

A time series of metal concentrations is assessed for status if:

  • there is at least one year with data in the period 2010 to 2015
  • there are at least three years of data over the whole time series
  • a parametric model can be fitted to the data and used to estimate the mean concentration in the final monitoring year (or, occasionally, if a non-parametric test of status is applied)

The conditions are more stringent for trends. Specifically, a time series is assessed for trends if:

  • there is at least one year with data in the period 2010 to 2015
  • there are at least five years of data over the whole time series
  • a parametric model can be fitted to the data and used to estimate the trend in mean concentrations

Note that all trend assessments for individual time series and most status assessments are based on the fit of a parametric model. This is important because only the parametric results are passed into the regional assessments in the following sections. As it turns out, none of the metal time series were assessed for status using a non-parametric test.

The first tab below shows all the monitoring stations where there are individual time series assessments of trend or status for metals. The magenta circles are stations where there is a trend assessment for at least one metal, and the cyan cirles are stations where there are only status assessments. The areas delineated by the thinner black lines are the biogeographic regions; those delineated by the thicker black lines are the MSFD sub-regions.

The next set of tabs show the trend and status assessments for each metal in turn. The colours have the following meaning:

  • blue: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the Background Assessment Concentration (BAC)
  • orange: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the European Commission food standard (EC)
  • red: the mean concentration is not signficantly below the European Commission food standard (EC)

And the shapes have the following meaning:

  • downward triangle: the mean concentration is significantly decreasing (p < 0.05)
  • circle: there is no significant change in mean concentration (p > 0.05)
  • upward triangle: the mean concentration is significantly increasing (p < 0.05)

The final set of tabs give:

  • the number of time series with upwards, downwards or no trend in each biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region
  • the same information presented as proportions
  • the number of time series with blue, orange, or red status in each biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region
  • the same information presented as proportions

Note that orange is used to show time series where the mean concentration is significantly below the EC, rather than green (which is used for metals in sediment and other contaminant groups in biota and sediment when compared to their EC ‘equivalent’). This is because the EC is a food standard to protect human health rather than an environmental standard to protect sensitive marine organisms. A time series significantly below the EC therefore cannot be used to infer good environmental status and orange is used to reflect ths ambiguous status. Clearly, a time series that is not significantly below the EC indicates concern and is coloured red.


Stations


HG


CD


PB


Trend summary (numbers)

Number of time series with upwards, downwards or no trend by biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region

MSFD sub-region biogeographic region status HG CD PB total
Greater North Sea Northern North Sea upward trend 4 4 4 12
no trend 13 12 13 38
downward trend 4 3 2 9
Southern North Sea upward trend 0 3 0 3
no trend 10 8 9 27
downward trend 1 0 1 2
E Channel upward trend 0 1 0 1
no trend 2 1 2 5
downward trend 0 0 0 0
total upward trend 4 8 4 16
no trend 25 21 24 70
downward trend 5 3 3 11
Celtic Seas Scottish Continental Shelf upward trend 0 3 2 5
no trend 6 3 5 14
downward trend 1 1 1 3
Minches & W Scotland upward trend 2 3 4 9
no trend 14 13 12 39
downward trend 0 0 0 0
Irish Sea upward trend 6 4 4 14
no trend 17 18 16 51
downward trend 4 5 6 15
W Channel & Celtic Sea upward trend 0 0 0 0
no trend 2 2 2 6
downward trend 0 0 0 0
total upward trend 8 10 10 28
no trend 39 36 35 110
downward trend 5 6 7 18


Trend summary (proportions)

Proportion of time series with upwards, downwards or no trend by biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region

MSFD sub-region biogeographic region status HG CD PB total
Greater North Sea Northern North Sea upward trend 19 21 21 20
no trend 62 63 68 65
downward trend 19 16 11 15
Southern North Sea upward trend 0 27 0 9
no trend 91 73 90 85
downward trend 9 0 10 6
E Channel upward trend 0 50 0 17
no trend 100 50 100 83
downward trend 0 0 0 0
total upward trend 12 25 13 17
no trend 73 66 77 72
downward trend 15 9 10 11
Celtic Seas Scottish Continental Shelf upward trend 0 43 25 23
no trend 86 43 63 63
downward trend 14 14 12 14
Minches & W Scotland upward trend 12 19 25 19
no trend 88 81 75 81
downward trend 0 0 0 0
Irish Sea upward trend 22 15 15 17
no trend 63 67 62 64
downward trend 15 18 23 19
W Channel & Celtic Sea upward trend 0 0 0 0
no trend 100 100 100 100
downward trend 0 0 0 0
total upward trend 15 19 19 18
no trend 75 69 67 70
downward trend 10 12 14 12


Status summary (numbers)

Number of time series with each status by biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region

MSFD sub-region biogeographic region status HG CD PB total
Greater North Sea Northern North Sea blue 0 8 0 8
orange 27 15 27 69
red 0 4 0 4
Southern North Sea blue 0 1 0 1
orange 11 9 10 30
red 0 1 0 1
E Channel blue 0 0 0 0
orange 2 2 2 6
red 0 0 0 0
total blue 0 9 0 9
orange 40 26 39 105
red 0 5 0 5
Celtic Seas Scottish Continental Shelf blue 0 4 3 7
orange 8 4 5 17
red 0 0 0 0
Minches & W Scotland blue 0 3 4 7
orange 18 15 14 47
red 0 0 0 0
Irish Sea blue 0 3 2 5
orange 30 27 26 83
red 0 0 2 2
W Channel & Celtic Sea blue 0 1 0 1
orange 4 3 4 11
red 0 0 0 0
total blue 0 11 9 20
orange 60 49 49 158
red 0 0 2 2


Status summary (proportions)

Proportion of time series with each status by biogeographic region and MSFD sub-region

MSFD sub-region biogeographic region status HG CD PB total
Greater North Sea Northern North Sea blue 0 30 0 10
orange 100 55 100 85
red 0 15 0 5
Southern North Sea blue 0 9 0 3
orange 100 82 100 94
red 0 9 0 3
E Channel blue 0 0 0 0
orange 100 100 100 100
red 0 0 0 0
total blue 0 22 0 8
orange 100 65 100 88
red 0 13 0 4
Celtic Seas Scottish Continental Shelf blue 0 50 38 29
orange 100 50 62 71
red 0 0 0 0
Minches & W Scotland blue 0 17 22 13
orange 100 83 78 87
red 0 0 0 0
Irish Sea blue 0 10 7 6
orange 100 90 86 92
red 0 0 7 2
W Channel & Celtic Sea blue 0 25 0 8
orange 100 75 100 92
red 0 0 0 0
total blue 0 18 15 11
orange 100 82 82 88
red 0 0 3 1


Regional assessment - methods

Tabulating the number of time series with each status category by region provides a quick summary of the individual time series results. However, it does not provide an objective regional assessment of status. Similarly, tabulating the number of time series with an upward or downward trend does not provide an objective regional assessment of trend. This section describes how the individual time series results can by synthesised in a meta-analysis to assess both status and trend at the regional level.

Trends

For a regional trend assessment, the trend in each time series is summarised by the estimated change in log concentration over the last twenty years (or shorter if the time series doesn’t extend that far back). Regional trends are then estimated by fitting the following linear mixed model by restricted maximum likelihood:

  • response: trend (yearly change in log concentration)
  • fixed model: region * metal
  • random model: station + trend estimation variation + residual variation

The fixed model means that a separate regional trend is estimated for each metal. The random model has three terms:

  • station allows for variation in trend between stations common to all metals
  • trend estimation variation is the variance of the trend estimates from the individual time series analysis, assumed known and fixed
  • residual variation is the variation that cannot be explained by any of the fixed effects or the other random effects

The meta-analysis is restricted to time series from monitoring stations that are classified as ‘representative’. ‘Baseline’ stations (those with near pristine conditions or only subject to very diffuse inputs) are omitted because any trends there will likely be caused by different processes to those at representative stations. Similarly ‘impacted’ stations (those close to a point source) are omitted because trends there will likely reflect changes due to the point source, and will be ‘unrepresentative’ at the regional level.

The meta-analysis is further restricted to regions and metal combinations with at least three trend stations with good geographic spread. Three stations is considered the minimum required to provide some sort of evidence base at the regional level.

Status

For a regional status assessment, the status of each time series is summarised by the difference between the estimated mean log concentration in the final monitoring year and the log assessment concentration. This ensures that status is always measured on the same scale, even though the assessment criterion might vary between metals and time series. Essentially the same linear mixed model as for trends is then fitted:

  • response: status (mean log concentration - log assessment concentration)
  • fixed model: region * metal
  • random model: station + status estimation variation + residual variation

where status estimation variation is the variation in the status estimates from the individual time series analysis, assumed known and fixed.

There are no restrictions on the time series used in the status meta-analysis based on the classification of the monitoring station; time series from baseline, representative and impacted stations are all included.

Again, the meta-analysis is restricted to regions and metal combinations with at least three status stations with good geographic spread.

Presentation

The results of both the trend and status regional assessments are back-transformed for presentation. The estimated regional trend is then interpreted as the percentage yearly change in concentration and the estimated regional status as the ratio of the mean regional concentration to the assessment concentration. To illustrate the latter, a value of 1 indicates that the mean regional concentration is equal to the assessment concentration; a value of 0.5 indicates that it is half the assessment concentration, and a value of 2 indicates that it is twice the assessment concentration.


Regional assessment - availability of time series

This section provides more detail on the number and geographic spread of the time series available for the meta-analyses. The map shows the stations with parametric trend and status assessments having excluded trend assessments at baseline and impacted stations. The magenta circles are stations where there is a trend assessment for at least one metal, and the cyan cirles are stations where there are only status assessments.

The following regions have an insufficient number or time series or spread of stations and are excluded from the regional assessment:

  • trend: E Channel, W Channel & Celtic Sea
  • status: E Channel



Regional trends

The first 3 tabs show:

  • Regional trends by metal: regional trend estimates with pointwise 95% confidence limits by metal
  • Regional trends by region: regional trend estimates with pointwise 95% confidence limits by region
  • Individual time series: the trend estimates from the individual time series on which the regional assessment is based. The estimates from regions with insufficient geographic spread (and excluded from the meta-analysis) are also shown.

The symbols in all these plots have the following interpretation:

  • downward triangle: the mean concentration is significantly decreasing (p < 0.05)
  • circle: there is no change in mean concentration (p > 0.05)
  • upward triangle: the mean concentration is significantly increasing (p < 0.05)

The final tab show the estimates of the regional trend by metal.


Regional trends by metal


Regional trends by region


Individual time series



Estimates by region and metal

This table shows the estimates of the regional trend by determinand:

  • trend: the estimated mean yearly change in log concentration across the region (multiplied by 100 for presentation)
  • se: the corresponding standard error
  • lower, upper: the corresponding pointwise 95% confidence limits
  • % yearly change: the estimated mean % yearly change in concentration across the region
  • %yc lower, %yc upper: the corresponding pointwise 95% confidence limits


biogeographic region metal trend se lower upper % yearly change %yc lower %yc upper
Northern North Sea HG -0.18 1.14 -2.41 2.04 -0.18 -2.38 2.07
CD 1.29 1.18 -1.01 3.60 1.30 -1.01 3.66
PB 0.22 1.29 -2.31 2.75 0.22 -2.29 2.79
Southern North Sea HG -0.15 1.50 -3.10 2.80 -0.15 -3.05 2.84
CD 4.76 1.50 1.81 7.71 4.87 1.83 8.01
PB -2.29 1.87 -5.95 1.36 -2.27 -5.78 1.37
Scottish Continental Shelf HG -0.11 1.91 -3.85 3.64 -0.11 -3.78 3.71
CD 1.64 1.80 -1.89 5.18 1.65 -1.88 5.31
PB 1.30 1.95 -2.52 5.13 1.31 -2.49 5.27
Minches & W Scotland HG 3.29 1.54 0.28 6.31 3.35 0.28 6.51
CD 2.25 1.43 -0.54 5.05 2.28 -0.54 5.18
PB 3.92 1.56 0.86 6.98 4.00 0.86 7.23
Irish Sea HG 0.21 0.99 -1.72 2.14 0.21 -1.71 2.16
CD -1.41 1.03 -3.44 0.61 -1.40 -3.38 0.62
PB -2.01 1.12 -4.20 0.18 -1.99 -4.11 0.18


Regional status compared to the European Commission food standard (EC)

The first 3 tabs show:

  • Regional status by metal: regional status estimates with pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limits by metal
  • Regional status by region: regional status estimates with pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limits by region
  • Individual time series: the status estimates from the individual time series on which the regional assessment is based. The estimates from regions with insufficient geographic spread (and excluded from the meta-analysis) are also shown.

The symbols in all the plots have the following interpretation:

  • blue: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the Background Assessment Concentration (BAC)
  • orange: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the EC
  • red: the mean concentration is not significantly below the EC

Note that to see why some points are coloured blue, it is necessary to look ahead to the next section, where status is compared to the BAC. Unfortunately, it isn’t easy to present the assessment of status relative to the EC with the assessment of status relative to the BAC because the ratio of the BAC to the EC can vary between metals, between regions and, for biota, between species.

The final tab show the estimates of the regional status by metal.


Regional status by metal


Regional status by region


Individual time series



Estimates by region and metal

This table shows the estimates of regional status by determinand:

  • status: the estimated mean log concentration minus the log EC
  • se: the corresponding standard error
  • upper: the corresponding pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limit
  • concentration: the estimated mean concentration relative to the EC
  • conc upper: the corresponding pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limit


biogeographic region metal status se upper concentration conc upper
Northern North Sea HG -2.31 0.14 -2.08 0.10 0.12
CD -1.39 0.14 -1.17 0.25 0.31
PB -1.80 0.14 -1.57 0.17 0.21
Southern North Sea HG -1.98 0.22 -1.62 0.14 0.20
CD -1.11 0.22 -0.75 0.33 0.47
PB -2.90 0.23 -2.52 0.05 0.08
Scottish Continental Shelf HG -3.31 0.25 -2.90 0.04 0.06
CD -1.90 0.25 -1.49 0.15 0.22
PB -2.02 0.25 -1.61 0.13 0.20
Minches & W Scotland HG -2.87 0.17 -2.59 0.06 0.08
CD -1.78 0.17 -1.50 0.17 0.22
PB -2.02 0.18 -1.73 0.13 0.18
Irish Sea HG -2.13 0.13 -1.92 0.12 0.15
CD -1.85 0.13 -1.63 0.16 0.20
PB -1.74 0.14 -1.52 0.18 0.22
W Channel & Celtic Sea HG -2.50 0.36 -1.91 0.08 0.15
CD -2.75 0.37 -2.14 0.06 0.12
PB -1.64 0.36 -1.04 0.19 0.35


Regional status compared to the Background Assessment Concentration (BAC)

The first 3 tabs show:

  • Regional status by metal: regional status estimates with pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limits by metal
  • Regional status by region: regional status estimates with pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limits by region
  • Individual time series: the status estimates from the individual time series on which the regional assessment is based. The estimates from regions with insufficient geographic spread (and excluded from the meta-analysis) are also shown.

The symbols in all the plots have the following interpretation:

  • blue: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the BAC
  • orange: the mean concentration is significantly (p < 0.05) below the European Commission food standard (EC)
  • red: the mean concentration is not significantly below the EC

The final tab show the estimates of the regional status by metal.


Regional status by metal


Regional status by region


Individual time series



Estimates by region and metal

This table shows the estimates of regional status by determinand:

  • status: the estimated mean log concentration minus the log BAC
  • se: the corresponding standard error
  • upper: the corresponding pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limit
  • concentration: the estimated mean concentration relative to the BAC
  • conc upper: the corresponding pointwise upper one-sided 95% confidence limit


biogeographic region metal status se upper concentration conc upper
Northern North Sea HG 0.74 0.19 1.04 2.09 2.84
CD 1.37 0.18 1.67 3.93 5.33
PB 1.22 0.19 1.52 3.37 4.59
Southern North Sea HG 0.84 0.29 1.32 2.32 3.75
CD 2.20 0.29 2.68 9.02 14.59
PB 0.71 0.31 1.22 2.04 3.37
Scottish Continental Shelf HG 0.18 0.34 0.73 1.19 2.08
CD -0.09 0.34 0.47 0.92 1.59
PB -0.11 0.34 0.45 0.90 1.57
Minches & W Scotland HG 0.46 0.23 0.84 1.59 2.32
CD 0.35 0.23 0.73 1.42 2.07
PB 0.26 0.23 0.64 1.30 1.91
Irish Sea HG 0.92 0.18 1.20 2.50 3.34
CD 0.76 0.18 1.06 2.15 2.88
PB 1.17 0.18 1.46 3.22 4.32
W Channel & Celtic Sea HG 0.38 0.48 1.17 1.46 3.23
CD 0.36 0.49 1.17 1.44 3.23
PB 1.85 0.48 2.64 6.35 14.07